Hulu Renews ‘All’s Fair’ for Season 2

by

I’ve been watching Hulu’s All’s Fair, starring Kim Kardashian, and while the first season isn’t over yet, good news – it’s been renewed for a second! Honestly, it wasn’t a huge shock. Ryan Murphy is a big name, and Hulu clearly wants to keep working with him. Plus, let’s face it, Kim Kardashian has been a reality TV fixture for twenty years – she brings a built-in audience. The interesting thing is, the show hasn’t exactly wowed the critics, so this renewal feels a little unexpected, but definitely welcome if you’re a fan.

Okay, so the show All’s Fair is getting another season, which is… surprising, to say the least. Deadline broke the news, but honestly, the critical response hasn’t been great. Rotten Tomatoes has 30 reviews tallied up, and the show is sitting at a measly 3% positive. Now, we all know Rotten Tomatoes isn’t the be-all and end-all, but that score basically means most critics found more to dislike than like in this first season. It wasn’t universally hated, just… largely disappointing, apparently.

Ryan Murphy has a history of creating popular TV shows like Glee, American Horror Story, 9-1-1, and Monster that attract large audiences, even if they don’t always win over critics. However, shows such as Feud, Pose, and American Crime Story demonstrate his ability to produce critically acclaimed hits that viewers also love.

What Is ‘All’s Fair’ About?


Hulu

Kim Kardashian isn’t the only familiar face in the cast! Several actors who’ve worked with director Ryan Murphy before are also starring, including Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Teyana Taylor, Matthew Noszka, Sarah Paulson, and Glenn Close. Hulu has described the show as follows:

A group of talented divorce lawyers—all women—decide to leave their established, male-run firm and start their own, highly competitive practice. These strong, intelligent, and complex women handle messy, high-profile divorces filled with secrets and betrayals, not only for their clients but also as they deal with their own personal challenges and shifting loyalties. In a world driven by wealth and where relationships often feel like a fight, they don’t just participate—they redefine the rules.

It’s currently unknown what the second season of All’s Fair will be about, but it likely won’t be structured as a completely new story each season like other shows created by the same producer.

Similar to much of Murphy’s work, the show All’s Fair blends different styles and genres. Director Anthony Hemingway told The Hollywood Reporter that he believes the show received negative feedback primarily because viewers had preconceived notions about it before it even aired. He explained to the publication:

The show isn’t living up to some viewers’ expectations. The combination of ‘legal’ and ‘drama’ led people to anticipate something different than what the show actually delivers. It was intentionally created as a bit of escapism and wish fulfillment, offering a lighthearted experience when many are looking for that. The show doesn’t take itself too seriously, and that’s by design – it’s not meant to be a comedy, but it avoids being overly dramatic.

This show aims to feel like real conversations, but with a unique style. I genuinely think it works, and I’m confident it will resonate with people. We’re proud of what we’ve created, even if not everyone immediately understands it. We encourage viewers to approach it with an open mind – it’s different in tone and will become more relatable as it develops.

The first season of All’s Fair will end on December 9th, and the remaining episodes might change what critics think of the show.

Read More

2025-11-25 01:19