Why Visiting Gettysburg Changed My Perspective on the Iconic Civil War Film

by

We’ve recently returned from a fortnight-long journey that took us to various destinations, ranging from national parks to Colonial Williamsburg and beaches on the Chesapeake Bay. Yet, the most memorable part of our trip was undoubtedly the last leg – spending two days in Gettysburg, a location steeped in history as it witnessed one of the American Civil War’s pivotal battles and one of the nation’s deadliest conflicts.

Upon returning home, one of my initial actions was to catch up on Ronald F. Maxwell’s “Gettysburg”, a four-hour masterpiece that portrays the bravery, destruction, and significance of the three-day conflict between Union and Confederate troops in July 1863. I must say, it was worth the wait as it ranks among the most acclaimed Civil War films ever made. Let me explain why…

Understanding The Sheer Size Of The Battlefield Made The 1993 Movie Hit Harder

As a cinema enthusiast hailing from the deep South, where my hometown served as the last capital of the Confederacy, I’ve developed an extensive understanding of the American Civil War. I’ve attended numerous battle reenactments, penned numerous essays on the subject throughout my educational journey, and have paid countless visits to Vicksburg, standing before its colossal cannons overlooking the Mississippi more times than I can remember.

Initially, I hadn’t fully grasped the immense scale of the Gettysburg battlefield until I visited it during my vacation. It’s more than just a large field where over 50,000 soldiers were injured, captured, or lost their lives; it encompasses numerous varied locations scattered across an expansive area, located only a few miles north of the Mason-Dixon Line.

Watching the film at home became deeply moving after I had personally experienced Gettysburg, and I genuinely believe that its emotional weight wouldn’t have been as profound if I hadn’t just returned from visiting the battlefield myself.

Having Visited The Battlefield And Museum Just Days Earlier, It Was Easier To Keep Up With All The Major Characters And Events

Similar to many top-notch war films, “Gettysburg” packs an abundance of content throughout its 4.5-hour duration (I opted for the extended version, while the standard cut is only 20 minutes shorter). Remarkably, I was able to recall a wealth of information, characters, and events from the Battle of Gettysburg after my recent museum visit. Despite this prior knowledge, it was challenging at times to follow all the individuals and occurrences that unfolded.

In my own words, diving into the world of “Band of Brothers” has been an enlightening journey. While it’s straightforward to follow the main characters like Martin Sheen as Robert E. Lee or Tom Berenger as James Longstreet on the Confederate side, and Jeff Daniels as Joshua Chamberlain and Sam Elliott as John Buford on the Union side, there are numerous lesser-known characters whose historical impact would have gone unnoticed if I hadn’t dedicated ample time to learning about their stories. This is true not only for these individual characters but also for the myriad of conflicts that unfolded during the three-day battle.

I Stood In The Very Spot Where Many Of The Movie’s Most Iconic Scenes Took Place, And That Added A Lot To The Experience

Among the most fascinating aspects of Gettysburg is that many pivotal scenes from the movie were actually filmed at the Gettysburg National Military Park, as shared by Turner Classic Movies (notably, these projects held great significance for Ted Turner). Even though the entire film wasn’t shot on this historic ground, crucial battles like those on Little Round Top and Devil’s Den, two of the deadliest spots during the battle, were accurately recreated at the very places where they originally transpired approximately 130 years prior.

I bring up these two places, Little Round Top and Devil’s Den, as they left a profound impression on me during my battlefield tour. Standing atop the rocky heights of Little Round Top or traversing Devil’s Den stirred thoughts about what it would have been like amidst the intense fighting. After watching Gettysburg, I was able to visualize the sights experienced by soldiers from both sides during those critical days in July 1863.

The Movie Has A Great Deal Of Authenticity, And I Think That Would Have Been Lost On Me Beforehand

Despite not being as violent as the real battle, I still view “Gettysburg” as an authentic war film due to its high level of historical accuracy throughout its extended runtime. Many key events from the three-day battle are accurately portrayed in sequence and in a manner that closely mirrors history, given the constraints of the format.

Though some beards appeared as if they were decaying animals or props from a school play (honestly, Tom Berenger’s beard resembled a broom haphazardly stuck to his face), other aspects were meticulously recreated with care and accuracy, particularly the film’s climactic scenes. I believe I would have appreciated this part of the movie regardless of visiting Gettysburg, but like many details, it might not have been as impactful without that experience.

Watching The Movie’s Depictions Of Little Round Top And Pickett’s Charge Was Powerful

Among numerous impactful scenes from the movie “Gettysburg”, two that deeply moved me were the sequences set on Little Round Top towards the end of the first act, and Pickett’s Charge during the final, intense battle. Visiting the actual sites of these crucial battle events a few days prior to watching the film enriched my understanding of these scenes and amplified their emotional impact.

It’s truly captivating to see Jeff Daniels portray Joshua Chamberlain so convincingly as he led his Union troops in successfully defending against a Confederate attack on the second day of battle, and Stephen Lang equally impresses as George Pickett during the unsuccessful final Rebel attempt to crush the Yankees. The moment when Pickett informs the generals that there’s nothing left but himself is incredibly moving.

In essence, I believe I would have enjoyed the book ‘Gettysburg’ regardless of not visiting the battlefield. However, strolling on the grounds where countless men lost their lives over 160 years ago significantly enhanced my experience and created a vivid, unforgettable cinematic moment.

Read More

2025-07-18 23:10