This Hilarious, 31-Year-Old Movie Was a Box Office Juggernaut, And Should Come Back as a Dark Reboot

by

As a big fan, I’ve noticed that whether a comic book movie succeeds – especially now when they’re so popular – really comes down to how well it sticks to the original comics. It’s always good to try and surprise people, but so often, dedicated fans get upset if the movie changes too much from what we already know and love – not just the main story or *why* characters do what they do, but even the overall feeling of the comic. However, sometimes filmmakers can get away with making changes if most people watching don’t even realize the movie is based on a comic book in the first place. A really great example of this is .

Actually, director Chuck Russell’s 1994 supernatural comedy was based on a short-lived comic book series created by John Arcudi and Doug Mahnke. Dark Horse Comics published it from 1989 to 1991, and it later led to several sequels and related stories. However, those who enjoyed the film and want to read the comic should know that it’s quite different. The same funny, playful energy that made Jim Carrey popular with younger viewers isn’t really present. In fact, some believe that helped it become a box office success, earning $352 million globally and receiving an 81% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. But is it too late to bring the franchise back with a fresh take that leans into the darker elements?

The Mask Is The Ultimate Jim Carrey Movie

For me, 1994 is the year Jim Carrey truly became the comedic force we all know and love. That was the year he had everyone roaring with laughter in Dumb and Dumber, playing the hilariously childish Lloyd Christmas, and gave what I consider his best performance as the wonderfully wacky Ace Ventura: Pet Detective. But if I had to pick *one* film from that year – or even his whole career – that really showcases everything he does best as a comedian, it absolutely has to be The Mask.

The comedian skillfully juggles two roles: the clumsy banker Stanley Ipkiss and the confident, energetic, and seemingly all-powerful cartoon character he transforms into with a mysteriously found mask. Throughout it all, he never hides his unique and quirky personality. He performs songs, dances, and delivers a fast-paced, hilarious range of celebrity impressions and pop culture jokes, resulting in a stunningly funny performance that elevates this unusual crime story to the status of a true classic.

Naturally, when talking about The Mask, it’s impossible not to highlight Cameron Diaz’s impressive film debut. While her portrayal of Tina, Stanley’s love interest, might not be her absolute best work, she immediately captivates audiences and showcases the star power that would define her Hollywood career the instant she appears on screen.

The Original Mask Comic Is Drenched In Pitch-Black Humor

The Mask is the movie that made a lot of younger audiences aware of Jim Carrey’s incredible talent, but it could have easily gone unnoticed if the film had stuck more closely to the original source material. The adaptation keeps the core idea of a mask granting its user limitless power, the character of Stanley Ipkiss and his smiling, green-faced other self, and even includes the same kind of humor that acknowledges the audience is watching. However, the film omits the extremely violent scenes that were a defining characteristic of the original graphic novel.

The original The Mask comic series from Dark Horse Comics was inspired by a character first created by Mike Richardson and further developed by Doug Mahnke and John Arcudi for the Dark Horse Presents anthology. Unlike the movie version, the anxious Ipkiss doesn’t use his newfound abilities to become a traditional “superhero.” Instead, he initially seeks revenge on those who have wronged him, eventually transforming into a violent criminal called the Big Head Killer, who selects victims completely at random.

This pattern repeats throughout the series and its follow-ups, as other characters become possessed by the magical object and succumb to violent urges, leading to some disturbingly strange and excessively gruesome scenes. Given the intense violence, he may have had a similar reaction to The Mask if the initial, more sinister script had been implemented.

The Movie Is Certainly Not Without Its Darkness

Although The Mask is definitely a much, much more lighthearted take on the original story, it doesn’t entirely disregard what came before. The movie actually includes a handful of scenes that reimagine some of the comic’s most surprising moments, with just a little bit of toning down.

Perhaps the most memorable scene is when “Stanley” gets back at the mechanics who sold him a terrible car by literally sticking their exhaust pipes where the sun doesn’t shine. In the comic book, this doesn’t just land them in the hospital – Big Head transforms their skin into coverings for those tailpipes. But the biggest source of unsettling darkness in the movie version of The Mask is arguably Peter Greene’s performance as the villain, Dorian Tyrell.

The actor, who also gave a disturbing performance in Pulp Fiction as Zed that same year, always plays the part of the cruel gangster with complete sincerity, even when he transforms into a green-skinned, red-haired giant while wearing The Mask. It’s almost as if Greene didn’t realize he was taking on a comedic role. But choosing to play it seriously allows him to be a genuinely frightening figure in what is otherwise a lighthearted story, and it makes Dorian one of the most memorable villains of his generation.

If The Mask Were Rebooted, It Should Be Even Darker

Given how incredibly successful the film was, the boost it gave to Jim Carrey’s career, and the fact that it continues to be enjoyed by new audiences, it was likely a good decision that the creators of The Mask left out the more controversial parts of the original comic. Still, the existence of this widely appealing version makes a strong case for revisiting the franchise with a new take that isn’t afraid to embrace the more daring material.

The upcoming Mask movie could be really interesting if it brought back Stanley Ipkiss and explored him becoming a true victim of the power that makes him commit terrible acts – think of it like Robert Louis Stevenson’s Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. While Jim Carrey was perfect in the role, Ryan Reynolds definitely has the energy and comedic skills to handle it. His natural charisma would actually make the character’s dark transformation even more surprising. A reboot could even work better as a series, starting with Ipkiss’s story like the original comics, and then eventually passing The Mask on to someone else – maybe Lt. Mitch Kellaway (played by Peter Riegert in the movie), which is something that actually happens in the original story.

The Mask, similar to Jim Carrey’s other popular films from 1994, led to the creation of an animated TV series. Interestingly, this series even included an episode that crossed over with the Ace Ventura: Pet Detective cartoon. Just like Ace and Dumb and Dumber, The Mask also got a sequel, but it wasn’t nearly as well-received as the original. Released eleven years later, Son of the Mask features Jamie Kennedy as a man who, while wearing the magical mask, fathers a child born with its powers.

The sequel doubled down on the silly, cartoon-like style of the first film, but unfortunately didn’t resonate with either critics or viewers. This led to disappointing ticket sales and a reputation as being one of the worst movies ever made. That’s why it’s time to revisit the franchise and correct past mistakes by creating a fresh take on The Mask, one that stays true to the spirit of the original comic book. Historically, many of the most successful reboots tend to be more serious in tone.

Read More

2025-10-05 03:08