‘The Pitt’ Season 2, Episode 3 Main Characters, Ranked by Likability

Okay, let me tell you about The Pitt Season 2. Fair warning, I’m about to dive into some spoilers! What’s really striking me is the cast – they’re fantastic, though not always easy to root for, and that complexity is brilliant. Even just three episodes in, this season has already wrecked me emotionally – I’ve cried, I’ve laughed, and I’ve been left pondering some seriously heavy stuff about life and loss. Honestly, the show hinges on those doctors. They’re seasoned, insightful, and clearly dedicated, and it’s a joy to watch them, even when the cases they’re dealing with are downright disturbing.

As a reviewer, one of my favorite things to do is gauge how much I connect with the characters, and each week I’ll be ranking the main players on this show based on their actions and how they handle the high-pressure situations they face. Let’s be real, we don’t love these doctors because they’re perfect—it’s their flaws and mistakes that make them relatable. They stumble, sometimes they don’t own up to it, but they generally seem to try and grow. So, a low ranking one week doesn’t mean I’ve lost respect for them! I’ll always be rooting for them to have a breakthrough, whether it’s a touching moment with a patient or supporting a colleague. Let’s dive into how everyone did in Season 2, Episode 3 of The Pitt, titled “9:00 A.M.”

Dennis Whitaker (Gerran Howell)


HBO Max

Dennis Whitaker doesn’t have a particularly standout role in this episode compared to the other doctors. He doesn’t make any mistakes, and it’s still great to see how much he’s grown since his first appearance in Season 1 of The Pitt. It’s really remarkable to see how confident he is now, especially if you remember how unlucky he used to be – he was always covered in blood!

Though Whitaker isn’t the most memorable character in The Pitt Season 2, Episode 3, he still has a few shining moments. He consistently shows kindness to patient Louie Cloverfield (Ernest Harden Jr.) and mentors Dr. Trinity Santos as she guides medical student James Ogilvie (Lucas Iverson). Ogilvie could learn a lot from Whitaker’s positive outlook and compassionate approach.

Victoria Javaidi (Shabana Azeez)


HBO Max

Look, I really like Victoria Javadi – she’s a smart, kind doctor, and always a pleasure to watch. But honestly, she didn’t get a ton to do in this episode. She’s a key part of the show, and it wouldn’t be the same without her, but this time around she mostly just ended up in a bit of a knowledge-off with James about a case. And we’ve seen that ‘who knows more?’ dynamic play out a million times on shows like this, so it didn’t really grab me. It did remind me, though, that I’m hoping James gets a more interesting story arc as the season goes on.

Javadi is still new, so she hasn’t had the opportunity to really stand out like the more seasoned doctors on the show. Throughout season 2 of The Pitt, she’s been a helpful team player, assisting with patients and contributing to diagnoses. Plus, she’s noticeably more courteous than some of her colleagues – James, in particular.

Dr. Mel King (Taylor Dearden)


HBO Max

Although Whitaker and Javadi are both capable and keep the emergency room functioning well in this episode, Dr. Mel King stands out by confidently handling a particularly challenging patient. This episode of The Pitt Season 2 jumps forward ten months, taking place on the Fourth of July, and features several intense cases, notably one involving the boisterous Hansen family.

Dr. King diagnoses Harlan Hansen (played by Sam Hennings) with an illness caused by a medication overdose. This case proves to be particularly challenging, initially lacking any obvious clues. However, Dr. King quickly identifies the issue, and it’s enjoyable and uplifting to see her solve it. Despite being stressed about an upcoming legal deposition, she still manages to provide excellent patient care. Go Mel!

Dr. Cassie McKay (Fiona Dourif)


HBO Max

Okay, so The Pitt isn’t always spot-on with the medical details – I’ll admit that. But Dr. McKay usually comes across as a really polite and professional doctor, and this episode is a good example. She deals with two tricky cases pretty well. A lot of the show’s appeal comes from characters having genuinely touching moments with patients, and while she doesn’t have tons of those, two conversations really stood out to me. There’s this older patient, Nathaniel Montrose, played by Michael Nouri, who playfully flirts with her, and she handles it beautifully, just calling him a charmer while she’s helping him. It could be a little awkward, but she’s clearly not threatened, and she’s really compassionate about what he’s going through – because, honestly, nobody wants to deal with that problem! (Ouch.)

Dr. McKay is particularly compassionate with her patient, Michael Williams (Derek Cecil), whose aggressive behavior is linked to a discovered mass. She also shows empathy towards Michael’s ex-wife, Gretchen (Amanda Schull), who understands that his actions during their divorce weren’t typical. Having faced challenges as a single parent herself, Dr. McKay readily connects with people who are genuine and open about their struggles.

Dr. Robby Robinavitch (Noah Wyle)


HBO Max

Dr. Robby Robinavitch was the top doctor last week, but he didn’t seem to be performing at his usual level. He also made a somewhat sarcastic comment at the end of the show, saying he should have left the night before. Some viewers might find this insensitive, given the difficult experiences of the patients he was treating.

Although some doctors are more immediately likable, Dr. Robby shares a particularly touching moment with patient Yana Kovalenko (played by Irana Dubova). Yana arrives at the ER with severe burns after accidentally knocking over a hot samovar when fireworks go off – a deeply emotional storyline that has resonated with viewers this season, as only The Pitt can deliver. The fireworks trigger memories of the 2018 Tree of Life synagogue shooting for Yana. Dr. Robby responds with genuine empathy, and even when she playfully teases him about his age and upcoming motorcycle trip, he remains kind and cheerful.

Dr. Trinity Santos (Isa Briones)


HBO Max

In Season 2, Episode 3 of The Pitt, Dr. Trinity Santos faces a particularly challenging situation: investigating a potential case of child abuse. She manages the delicate case skillfully, and it’s later revealed that the young patient, Kylie Connors (played by Annabelle Toomey), has a rare medical condition called ITP, which explains her bruising.

Dr. Santos handles Kylie’s often dramatic parents, Benny and Gina, with grace and composure, even when they argue publicly. This demonstrates significant personal growth; in the first season, she was often arrogant and kept her feelings hidden. Now, she prioritizes her patient’s well-being and, while still driven, appears much more caring than before.

Dr. Samira Mohan (Supriya Ganesh)


HBO Max

While the first season of The Pitt left viewers with some unanswered questions, it strongly emphasized the importance of doctors treating patients with genuine human connection. The show highlights the delicate balance between quick, life-saving action and providing compassionate, attentive care. Dr. Samira Mohan has consistently been portrayed as a particularly caring doctor, always making an effort to truly understand her patients. This is especially evident in Season 2, Episode 3, where she demonstrates empathy towards the family of a patient, Orlando Diaz, who is struggling with severe diabetes.

Dr. Mohan truly stands out in this episode because of her compassion. While talking with Orlando’s teenage daughter, Ana (Savannah Nicole Ruiz), who worries about her mom having to take the bus to the hospital, it’s clear Dr. Mohan is a very caring doctor. She’s understanding of the family’s financial struggles and treats them with respect. Unlike some doctors who might overlook the family’s emotional and financial hardships and only focus on the medical issues, Dr. Mohan makes a point of acknowledging and respecting their situation.

Dr. Baran Al-Hashimi (Sepideh Moafi)


HBO Max

Dr. Baran Al-Hashimi shines in her interactions with patient Mark Yee (Eugene Shaw) and his wife, Nancy (Angela Lin), clearly demonstrating she’s the perfect successor to Dr. Robby. She’s just as capable and composed as before, and like Dr. Robby, she remains calm and collected even in chaotic situations.

Dr. Al-Hashimi’s funny side really shines through in this episode. Like many good medical dramas, The Pitt doesn’t take itself too seriously, and she’s both intelligent and witty. There’s a particularly amusing scene where Dr. Al-Hashimi playfully tells Robby, “You’re free to see other people… I’m looking for cooperation, not commitment.” It’s a welcome moment, especially considering they didn’t initially seem like a good match. Robby is a great character, though he can be a bit stubborn, and it’s always fun to see other characters tease him about it.

Dana Evans (Katherine LaNasa)


HBO Max

It’s highly unlikely that Dana Evans, the head nurse on The Pitt, won’t be a fan favorite in every episode. She’s incredibly likable, and even though she doesn’t quite take the lead, she’s perfectly content with that, especially considering her kindness towards the doctor who earns the top spot this week.

Subscribe to the newsletter for deeper character rankings

Want more nuanced takes on who’s likable and why? Subscribe to the newsletter for extra character rankings, episode insights, and thoughtful TV analysis that keeps you debating shows like The Pitt and beyond.

By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s
Terms of Use
and
Privacy Policy
. You can unsubscribe anytime.

It’s hard to choose just one great moment with Dana from either season of The Pitt. She’s consistently kind and compassionate, but also stands her ground. A particularly touching scene involves her interaction with Troy Digby, a man experiencing homelessness who’s being cared for in the emergency room. She offers him genuine support, asking if ongoing care can be arranged, reminding him (and everyone) that we all need help sometimes. Despite witnessing so much pain, Dana remains respectful and fully present with each patient, like when she simply offers Dingy a sandwich – a small act of kindness that really stands out.

Dr. Frank Langdon (Patrick Ball)


HBO Max

Dr. Frank Langdon has made a fantastic return, and since being back at the hospital, he’s been a helpful, careful, and humble presence. This week, while treating a child who put beads in their nose, Langdon offers thoughtful parenting advice to new father Donnie Donahue (Brandon Mendez Homer), making him the most likable doctor of the week.

This scene could easily feel cheesy, but Langdon’s heartfelt quote from John O’Donohue – “may you be gentle and loving, clear and sure” – feels genuinely sweet. It shows he’s stopped trying to impress everyone and is now focused on connecting with others. He seems truly eager to rejoin the team and contribute positively. While it remains to be seen if this change lasts, it was a touching moment for his character.



5 Questions
Test Your ER Empathy: The Pitt S2E3 Likability Challenge
Your Top Score
Attempts
0
0
Report Error

Found an error? Send it info@movieweb.com so it can be corrected.

Read More

2026-01-23 18:38