The Mentalist Just Hit Netflix and is Required Viewing 11 Years Later

by

As a total TV junkie, I remember the 2000s being the time for crime shows, but even with all the forensic and police dramas out there, The Mentalist really stood apart. It was just…different. It originally aired starting in 2008 and ran for seven seasons, and I was thrilled to see all of it just dropped on Netflix! The show stars Simon Baker as Patrick Jane – he’s amazing as this former con man who uses his skills to help the CBI, all while secretly hunting the guy who murdered his family. Robin Tunney as Teresa Lisbon and Amanda Righetti as Grace Van Pelt are fantastic too – they really round out the team. It’s a seriously addictive show, and I’m excited to rewatch it (or for you to start watching!)

Created by Bruno Heller, The Mentalist offered a fresh take on the classic detective story, reminiscent of Sherlock Holmes. The show centered around Patrick Jane, a well-known psychic who built a successful career pretending to have supernatural abilities. Everything changed when he publicly claimed to have helped the California Bureau of Investigation profile the serial killer Red John. This angered Red John, who retaliated by murdering Jane’s wife and daughter. This tragic event launched Jane on a seven-season quest for revenge, making The Mentalist a popular series on Netflix.

The Release Of The Mentalist Coincides With Another, Brand New Crime Show

The show skillfully balanced self-contained cases each week with a larger, season-long story about Patrick Jane’s quest for revenge against Red John, the man responsible for his family’s murder. He worked with the CBI to solve crimes while simultaneously pursuing Red John.

Simon Baker was the main reason people watched the show. His character, Jane, was charming, funny, and deeply troubled – a classic hero for a crime drama. He had incredible chemistry with his partner, Teresa Lisbon, and also formed a unique connection with new agent Grace Van Pelt, as they both had difficult pasts.

The new Netflix crime series, Scarpetta, premiered on March 11th and brings Jamie Lee Curtis and Nicole Kidman (who also served as a producer) back together in a familiar storyline. The series is based on the popular novels by Patricia Cornwell and, after being stuck in development for many years – with previous attempts involving actors like Demi Moore – finally debuted in 2026.

I’m really intrigued by the new series featuring Nicole Kidman as Kay Scarpetta. She plays this incredibly sharp, but kind of reserved, forensic pathologist – basically, she solves really tough crimes by meticulously examining the evidence and DNA left behind. It’s not just about the cases, though. Her character has a complicated personal life, with a rocky marriage to her husband, Benton Wesley, played by Simon Baker, who’s an FBI profiler himself. And it seems like she’s carrying a lot of baggage from her past, which adds another layer of mystery to everything.

Kay has a strained relationship with her sister, Dorothy Scarpetta, and is portrayed in flashbacks by Amanda Righetti. Although Righetti and Baker didn’t share any scenes together in Scarpetta, casting them both in a procedural drama is a fun nod to their previous work on The Mentalist.

As a big fan of The Mentalist, I always loved the connection between Patrick Jane and Grace Van Pelt. It was so sweet to watch! Jane was consistently kind and encouraging to Grace, who was a bit of a sensitive soul. He clearly had a soft spot for her, almost like a brother, and it played out beautifully on screen. They had this fantastic dynamic where they’d playfully tease and disagree, especially when talking about things like religion or what happens after death. Those scenes were always a highlight for me.

Now that both shows are on streaming, it’s a great idea to watch The Mentalist either before or after finishing Scarpetta. This is one reason why…

Streaming Loves Crime Procedurals

Before streaming services, viewers had to wait for new episodes weekly or daily. Now, they can binge-watch multiple cases or episodes back-to-back without interruption.

With 151 episodes, The Mentalist is perfect for viewers who enjoy a long, engaging crime series with plenty of emotional depth. The show has recently been rediscovered by many thanks to streaming services like Netflix, which have helped revitalize interest in crime procedurals after a dip in popularity in the late 2010s and early 2020s.

Now that classic shows like The Mentalist are available for free streaming, fans can relive the enjoyment they originally felt watching them on television. With many episodes, engaging stories, and the satisfying feeling of seeing good triumph over evil, these shows are ideal for a cozy and comforting viewing experience.

Though tastes change over time, crime dramas consistently draw viewers. One reason is that they allow people to explore the darker aspects of human behavior from a secure distance. For example, the character Red John in The Mentalist was a particularly disturbing serial killer. He committed brutal murders, often leaving a chilling signature: giant smiley faces drawn with the victims’ blood. In one horrifying instance, he even used a victim’s blood to paint the toenails of her husband’s wife after killing her.

What really gets me hooked is the thrill of watching the investigators race against time to catch the criminal. It’s so captivating to see the police and experts, like Jane, meticulously analyze the clues, trying to make sense of everything. Honestly, it feels like I’m right there with them, trying to solve the mystery alongside the characters – it’s a truly immersive experience!

The Mentalist kept viewers hooked with both self-contained mysteries and a larger, season-long storyline about Red John. This combination, along with the lead character Patrick Jane’s incredible ability to read people and solve crimes, gave the show a captivating quality – it often felt like watching a magic trick as Jane revealed how he’d figured out who committed the crime based on the smallest clues.

Viewers find satisfaction in seeing justice served for the victims, whether it happens quickly within a single episode or later in the show’s final season. The chase to find the criminal and witness them face consequences is exciting for many, allowing the audience to experience a sense of justice through the characters.

This crime show delivers a compelling mix of suspense, excitement, and satisfying emotional moments. There’s a lasting appeal to watching thrilling crimes play out from the comfort of home, and the genre remains incredibly popular on streaming services.

The Mentalist Has Better Reviews Than Scarpetta

Crime shows are consistently popular on streaming services, often keeping viewers engaged for longer than newer, critically acclaimed dramas. While Scarpetta is a faster-paced and more recent offering, it hasn’t received particularly strong reviews.

Nicole Kidman and Julianne Curtis share a captivating on-screen connection, but the show hasn’t impressed most critics with its overall style and how the story unfolds. While audience scores are mixed, landing at 50%, it has surprisingly been picked up for another season.

Unlike some shows, The Mentalist has a very high 90% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, showing how popular it remains. These classic crime shows have stuck with viewers over the years, and many fans appreciate them even more now than when they first aired.

The Mentalist featured a compelling lead character, a truly menacing villain, and a gripping story of revenge and hardship that captivated audiences. Now that it’s available on Netflix, the show is poised to become popular with viewers around the world all over again.

5 Questions
Test Your Mentalist Mastery: Jane’s Tricks, Red John’s Reign, and Procedural Thrills
Your Top Score
—
Attempts
—
0
0
Report Error

Found an error? Send it so it can be corrected.

Read More

2026-03-15 01:10