Pluribus’ Biggest Criticism Makes No Sense At All

by

As a sci-fi fan, I’ve been following the buzz around Apple TV’s Pluribus, and it’s definitely living up to the hype – it’s become their most-watched show for a reason! Almost everyone loves it, but I’ve noticed one recurring complaint about how the story unfolds. While I get where those critics are coming from, I honestly think they’re missing what makes Pluribus so special, and it’s a bit frustrating to see that particular point constantly brought up.

The show Pluribus has become Apple TV+’s biggest hit ever, and critics overwhelmingly love it, giving it a 98% score on Rotten Tomatoes. No other science fiction series on the platform has received such high praise during its first season. However, despite this success, Pluribus is facing some unfair criticism for a particular creative choice.

Pluribus Season 1’s Biggest Criticism Makes Sense But Misses The Point Of The Show

Many viewers are criticizing Pluribus for being slow-paced and lacking excitement. This criticism likely comes from the fact that the first season only features one significant plot twist. However, the show’s deliberate slow pace and lack of constant action are intentional choices by its creators.

Despite being created by Vince Gilligan, the Apple TV sci-fi series Pluribus wasn’t intended to resemble his previous shows, Breaking Bad or Better Call Saul.

Rather than focusing on action, Pluribus explores the unsettling quiet and isolation experienced by those left after a major disaster, like the character Carol. It also highlights the paradox of feeling lonely even in a world that’s actually very connected. Unlike many post-apocalyptic stories that deal with a loss of morality or a simple fight between good and evil, this show takes a different approach.

However, Pluribus offers a nuanced and intricate exploration of humanity that requires careful consideration to fully understand.

What struck me most about Pluribus is how it forces you to really live with its characters, especially Carol and Manousos, to grasp the roots of their animosity towards the ‘Others’. Even when Carol seemingly sides with the Others near the end of the first season, abandoning Manousos, it’s vital not to see it as a simple change of heart. It’s a messy, complicated decision – a product of her deeply ingrained fear of being alone, and a reflection of how conditioned she’s become. The show doesn’t offer easy answers, and that’s its strength.

Had Pluribus moved quickly through the story, the contrast between Carol and Manousos’s human qualities and those of the Others wouldn’t have made such a strong and moving impact.

Pluribus’ Viewership Record Proves Its Criticism Did Not Bring It Down

A major downside of today’s streaming services is they encourage shows to focus on fast-paced action and immediate excitement. Because our attention spans are getting shorter, it’s becoming harder to enjoy shows like Pluribus that build stories gradually instead of offering instant thrills.

Surprisingly, even though it was quite different from typical shows, Pluribus became a huge hit and surpassed all other programs on Apple TV in viewership.

I’ve been so impressed with how well Pluribus has done! It feels refreshing to see a show that trusts its audience, offering a story that unfolds gradually and isn’t afraid to be a little mysterious. So many shows these days feel like they spoon-feed you everything, but Pluribus is different – it rewards your patience. I’m a huge fan, and I’m really hoping Apple TV doesn’t make us wait too long for season two! I can’t wait to see where the story goes next.

Read More

2026-01-04 05:59