In Just 13 Words, LOTR’s Sean Astin Convinced Peter Jackson He Was the Perfect Samwise Choice

by

Among the most terrifying moments in Peter Jackson‘s film trilogy is the encounter with the monstrous spider, Shelob. Just when Frodo Baggins believes he’s escaped her lair, she paralyzes him with venom and traps him in a web. Before she can eat him, Samwise Gamgee arrives with the Phial of Galadriel and Frodo’s sword, Sting. In a desperate fight, the courageous hobbit gardener drives Shelob away, forcing her back into the darkness. But when Sam looks at Frodo’s still, pale face, he fears the worst and believes his friend is dead, pleading, “Don’t leave me here alone. Don’t go where I can’t follow. Wake up.”

In the first Lord of the Rings movie, Sam vowed to stay with Frodo no matter what, but he found himself forced to leave him. He took the One Ring to complete Frodo’s mission, and then overheard Orcs discussing that Frodo hadn’t been killed by Shelob’s venom. While the scene ultimately proved to be a false alarm in The Return of the King, it was deeply moving and still resonates with viewers today, largely thanks to Sean Astin’s powerful performance as Sam. The director’s commentary reveals this was one of the audition scenes for Sam, and it was the scene that secured Astin the role.

Sean Astin Excelled in His Audition For The Lord of the Rings

During the audio commentary, screenwriter Philippa Boyens revealed that the creators of The Lord of the Rings were initially worried about casting Sean Astin. They weren’t sure if an American actor could convincingly pull off the English accent the character Samwise Gamgee needed – a West Country accent traditionally associated with rural farmers. Astin, having grown up in California, presented a challenge in achieving this specific sound.

Fran Walsh was initially unsure if Sean Astin could deliver the emotional depth required for the role, particularly with the dialogue. However, his performance during the scene where Frodo appears to die completely won her and the rest of the team over, as he delivered it perfectly and with genuine emotion. Walsh noted that English actors who auditioned for the part of Sam had difficulty conveying the same level of feeling. Both Graham Norton and another unnamed actor later confirmed they had auditioned for the role of Sam.

Honestly, if Sean Astin nailed that audition as much as he did in the final film, it’s totally understandable why the filmmakers were so impressed. I’ve cried at a few moments throughout the Lord of the Rings trilogy – Gandalf’s fall always gets me – but nothing hit quite like Sam’s reaction when he finds Frodo seemingly gone. It wasn’t just sadness about losing Frodo, but this incredible mix of self-blame for not protecting him and genuine fear about what would happen next. And he had to convey all of that in just about a minute, before the Orcs showed up! Astin really packed a huge emotional punch in such a short time, and it was brilliant.

Frodo and Sam’s Relationship Was Essential to The Lord of the Rings

You know, it’s funny listening to the commentary for The Return of the King. Sean Astin, who played Sam, actually felt really unsure about one particular scene! He told Elijah Wood he thought he’d overdone it, that it was too much. But looking back, he realized he hadn’t seen the whole picture – he hadn’t understood how that moment fit into the larger story of The Lord of the Rings at the time, and that’s why he doubted himself.

Looking back, if we’d seen a moment like that early on in the first movie, it probably would have felt too much, too soon. But by the time we got to the third film, around the middle of it, it just worked. We’d been with Sam and Frodo for so long – eight hours, or even more if you watched the extended cuts – and we really cared about what happened to them. When Frodo seemed to die, it was genuinely heartbreaking, and honestly, the story needed that emotional impact. It felt earned, and it deserved to be given the weight it had.

Choosing this particular scene for auditions was a smart move. It was essential that the actor playing Sam could convincingly show his deep connection with Frodo. Unlike the other heroes in The Lord of the Rings, who interacted with many different characters, Frodo and Sam were almost always together in the later movies. If their friendship didn’t feel genuine, it would have been hard for the audience to connect with their scenes.

Honestly, Sean Astin was Samwise Gamgee. He brought so much genuine emotion to the role, it was perfect. I was a little worried about his accent at first, but he really worked with those dialect coaches, Andrew Jack and Roisin Carty, to nail that West Country sound. It’s funny, I heard they almost didn’t cast him because of the audition scene they’d chosen! Apparently, if they’d gone with a different scene, he wouldn’t have gotten the part. Can you imagine? That would have been a disaster, almost as bad as if Frodo hadn’t made it to Mount Doom!

Read More

2025-11-05 17:11