All Her Fault Review: Sarah Snook & Dakota Fanning Are Superb In A Mystery Thriller That Masterfully Toyed With My Mind & Emotions

by

The story immediately grabs your attention and plunges you into a terrifying situation. It moves so quickly that you feel as panicked and frightened as Marissa Irvine (Sarah Snook) when she discovers her son, Milo (Duke McCloud), is missing. The show doesn’t waste any time establishing the suspense, trusting that the audience will instantly connect with a mother’s fear for her child. We learn Milo was supposedly at a playdate with another child, but he’s been kidnapped, and the series immediately throws us into the chaos.

This limited series isn’t a typical whodunit. While it starts with the disappearance of Milo, the story quickly becomes more about the complicated and often unsettling relationships between the characters. Uncovering who took Milo and why feels less important than watching how everyone interacts and accuses each other – and you’ll be hooked until the very end.

“All Her Fault” is a captivating read with plenty of unexpected turns, a satisfying conclusion, and a fast-paced plot that will keep you engaged from beginning to end. It expertly crafts a complex story filled with compelling characters.

All Her Fault Is A Tightly Written & Paced Mystery Thriller

The series, adapted from Andrea Mara’s novel, explores complex themes of modern womanhood. It focuses on how Marissa and Jenny juggle demanding careers, motherhood, and marriage, and the unfair pressure they face to be perfect. When Milo disappears, the media and public quickly criticize Marissa – questioning everything from her attention to text messages about a playdate to details about her work – while her husband, Peter, receives little scrutiny.

This series tells a complex and increasingly unsettling story, fueled by the tangled relationships between its characters. While the marriage of Marissa and Peter is central, the show also delves into Peter’s connections with his siblings, Brian and Lia, which are often just as captivating. Brian, who uses crutches due to a childhood accident, is constantly struggling, and Lia carries a heavy burden of guilt related to what happened to him.

The show’s title hints at a central idea, but the series offers surprisingly deep insights. Even supporting characters, like Detective Alcaras (Michael Peña), have complex pasts that explain their motivations. It’s clear that creator Megan Gallagher and her team truly understand the story they’re telling.

In just eight episodes, All Her Fault grabs your attention and doesn’t let go. The writing is sharp and the story moves quickly, hinting at deeper layers to be explored. This isn’t just a typical mystery; it’s a thoughtful look at its characters, how social class affects them, the power dynamics within a marriage, and how people try to control each other while pretending to be responsible. The series particularly excels at showing the pressures of trying to be a perfect mother and the exhaustion that can result.

I’m really hooked on this series! It manages to balance a lot of different storylines without ever feeling slow. I’m constantly trying to figure out who took Milo and why, but even that mystery gets overshadowed by the growing tension between Marissa’s family and her friend Colin. It’s been a great period for mystery thriller fans like me – with both All Her Fault and Down Cemetery Road on Apple TV, there’s been plenty to keep me on the edge of my seat!

The actors’ strong performances truly elevate the story. Kristin Snook, recognizable from HBO’s Succession, is particularly compelling as Marissa. She beautifully portrays the character’s complex emotions, bringing both fragility and resilience to the role. Throughout the season, Snook manages to keep the audience guessing, and she convincingly shows Marissa’s inner strength even as her life unravels and she faces difficult challenges.

As a film fan, I always loved the dynamic between Jenny and Marissa. They really let their guards down around each other, you know? They could just be – ditching the fake smiles and the carefully constructed images they presented to the world. Dakota Fanning is incredible as Jenny; she portrays this deep, underlying exhaustion that makes you feel like she’s constantly on the verge of either collapsing or exploding. What I appreciated was that the movie didn’t just make Jenny the supportive friend; it gave her a life and struggles of her own, and treated them with the same sensitivity as Marissa’s story. It felt really balanced and real.

Although the story mainly follows Marissa and Jenny, the supporting characters are what truly make the show compelling. Sophia Lillis shines as Jenny’s nanny, Carrie Finch, and Lacey delivers a nuanced performance as Peter, a father who struggles with expressing his care and often resorts to harsh words. The series keeps you guessing as to what each suspect is capable of when pushed to their limit. What makes ‘All Her Fault’ so good is how it explores this question and reveals the hidden depths of each character.

All episodes of All Her Fault are now streaming on Peacock.

Read More

2025-11-07 17:48