In Honor Of Doctor Who’s Most Miserable Christmas Special

by

For two decades, the Doctor Who Christmas special has become a near-annual event, and fans generally know what to anticipate. When a new Doctor is about to take over, the special is usually a big, dramatic finale with surprising twists and powerful enemies – think episodes like “The End of Time” and “The Time of the Doctor.” Otherwise, it’s typically a self-contained, family-friendly adventure, like “The Next Doctor” or “Last Christmas.”

Christmas specials of Doctor Who are all over the place in terms of quality. While episodes featuring a Doctor’s regeneration are usually excellent, stories like “A Christmas Carol” and “The Runaway Bride” really established the show’s signature Christmas style. Unfortunately, some episodes, such as “The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe,” are major disappointments – like receiving coal for Christmas, only to find out it wasn’t even for you and you aren’t getting any gifts at all.

“The Christmas Invasion,” David Tennant’s first full episode as the Doctor, is one of the better Doctor Who Christmas specials, but it’s surprisingly bleak when you revisit the 2005 story.

Doctor Who’s “The Christmas Invasion” Is Surprisingly Downbeat

As a big Doctor Who fan, when I first saw “The Christmas Invasion,” it seemed like exactly the kind of fun, action-packed adventure the show always does so well, especially around Christmas. I mean, killer Christmas trees, robot Santas, aliens invading – it had everything! Plus, the Doctor seemed unusually cheerful, and there was even a sword fight! Honestly, it looked like the perfect lighthearted, enjoyable episode to watch after a big Christmas dinner – a real treat!

“The Christmas Invasion” largely succeeds in what it sets out to do, but it’s a bit of a mixed bag tonally. While a solid episode overall, it also includes some very dark elements – widespread death, intense sadness, and even hints at suicide – which create a jarring contrast.

Honestly, it really bothered me how Rose Tyler reacted in “The Christmas Invasion.” We’ve seen companions struggle with a new Doctor before – think back to Ben and Polly or even Clara Oswald – but this was the first time it happened during Christmas! It just meant so much of Tennant’s first episode was filled with Rose complaining about losing her Doctor, getting upset that he wasn’t there for her, and feeling completely helpless without him. It was a bit much, to be honest.

As a huge Doctor Who fan, I always find it a bit jarring how downbeat Rose is for most of that first Christmas special. The Tenth Doctor doesn’t even really show up until the very end! I get that losing the Doctor would be incredibly upsetting – and Billie Piper plays that grief really well – but honestly, all the complaining just doesn’t quite fit the festive mood, you know?

Doctor Who’s First Christmas Villains Were Shockingly Dark

As a huge Doctor Who fan, I always thought the Sycorax had incredible potential. They looked fantastic – really striking and a bit terrifying – and their whole culture, built around this idea of honor and combat, was genuinely interesting. Plus, a massive spaceship parked over London? Come on, that’s awesome! You’d expect a Christmas villain to go for world domination, maybe mess with Santa, or even try to steal the Doctor’s energy. But honestly, the Sycorax took a really dark turn. Their thing was… making people, even kids, commit suicide by jumping off buildings. It was a shockingly grim direction for a festive episode, and a bit of a letdown considering how cool they initially seemed.

I have to admit, even for an episode not about Christmas, that one felt surprisingly heavy. It wasn’t that the people were choosing to jump, they were being controlled, but seeing them on the ledge while their families pleaded with them… it hit a little too close to home. Considering it was a Christmas special, I think they could have gone with a more lighthearted, fantastical enemy. Later episodes definitely did – with baby-stealing goblins and villains like Scrooge – but this one felt different, more raw.

Ebaster Report

Dive into the world of movies and TV shows with Ebaster, your source for news, reviews, and exclusive content.

Ebaster Report

Dive into the world of movies and TV shows with Ebaster, your source for news, reviews, and exclusive content.

By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

The ending of “The Christmas Invasion” features Prime Minister Harriet Jones making a controversial decision: she destroys the Sycorax ship, killing all those on board, even though they seemed to be retreating. This raises difficult questions about right and wrong, much like when the Brigadier attacked the Silurians in a previous Doctor Who story. However, the sheer scale of the killing leaves a disturbing feeling, spoiling what should be a joyful holiday.

If the somber mood wasn’t enough, “The Christmas Invasion” adds one last unsettling detail. While snow falls, briefly offering a cheerful moment, the Tenth Doctor reveals it’s actually the ashes of the Sycorax. It’s a darkly festive way for Doctor Who to wish everyone a Merry Christmas.

Read More

2025-12-20 21:09