Emma Thompson’s Unbeatable Sense And Sensibility Adaptation: 1995 Classic Still Reigns Supreme

by

Emma Thompson is one of Britain’s most beloved actresses and a true cultural icon. She’s famous for her incredible performances, including a highly acclaimed adaptation of a classic novel written two centuries ago. Thompson began her career with the famous Footlights comedy group, and she’s remarkably skilled at both acting and writing.

Emma Thompson had an early breakthrough playing the lead in a film adaptation of Jane Austen’s classic novel. She not only starred in the period drama, but also wrote the screenplay, and won an Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay. This made her the only person ever to receive Oscars for both acting and writing.

1995’s Sense & Sensibility Is Still The Best Version

In 1995, Emma Thompson worked with director Ang Lee to create a film adaptation of Sense and Sensibility. The movie tells the well-known story of the Dashwood sisters, Elinor (played by Thompson) and Marianne (Kate Winslet), who come from a comfortable family but suddenly find themselves in financial trouble. To secure their future, the sisters look for husbands, with Hugh Grant and Alan Rickman portraying their potential partners.

Although Sense and Sensibility takes place within the specific social rules and expectations of late 18th-century England, the movie’s script made the characters feel incredibly real and easy to understand. By focusing on timeless issues like logic, feelings, and money problems, the story makes you genuinely care about what happens to the Dashwood sisters.

The success of Thompson’s adaptation of Sense and Sensibility is clear: both she and Kate Winslet received Academy Award nominations for their acting, and Thompson’s Oscar win for screenwriting was a historic first. The film also sparked renewed interest in Jane Austen’s novels, introducing her clever writing to a wider audience.

Look, as a period drama, this film truly stands apart. It’s no shock that people keep trying to bring Austen’s story to the screen, but honestly? Neither the 2008 adaptation nor the new 2024 version even comes close to Thompson’s work. It’s still the definitive portrayal of the Dashwood sisters’ passionate loves and unspoken desires – a benchmark others just haven’t met.

The 2008 version of Sense and Sensibility was more explicit in its portrayal of romance and sexuality than Austen’s original novel, showing scenes that were only hinted at in the book. This three-part BBC miniseries was well-received for its fresh take on the story, though it didn’t quite reach the same level of success as the film adaptation by Emma Thompson.

The 2024 version tried to be different by casting mostly Black actors, which brought a new focus on race not seen in earlier versions. Although the film’s casting was noteworthy, it lacked the quality and emotional impact of the original 1995 movie.

There Have Been More Sense & Sensibility Adaptations Since 1995

I’m a big fan of Sense and Sensibility, and it’s amazing how many times this story has been retold! Before Emma Thompson’s fantastic movie came out, it had actually been made for TV twice already. Once as a TV movie way back in 1971, and then again as a seven-part series in 1981. It’s just a classic story that keeps getting reimagined, which I love!

Austen’s story continues to be popular globally, inspiring adaptations like the 2000 Tamil film Kandukondain Kandukondain and the Hindi soap opera Kumkum Bhagya, which draws inspiration from the original plot. The Malayalam soap opera Kasthooriman was also significantly influenced by the story of the Dashwood sisters.

Over the last two centuries, Sense and Sensibility has been adapted and reimagined in countless ways – from audio dramas like Helen Edmundson’s BBC Radio version to stage musicals. Considering how often it’s been retold, the continued popularity of Emma Thompson’s adaptation is particularly noteworthy.

Another Sense & Sensibility Adaptation Is Happening – Can It Finally Beat Emma Thompson’s Version?

Emma Thompson’s 1995 film adaptation of Sense and Sensibility remains a classic, but that hasn’t stopped others from attempting their own versions. Focus Features is currently working on a new adaptation, set to release in 2025, starring Daisy Edgar-Jones as Elinor and Esme Creed-Miles as Marianne (according to Variety).

Despite being relatively new filmmakers, director Georgia Oakley and writer Diana Reid have created a fresh take on Sense and Sensibility with the support of Focus Features, a major studio known for successful period pieces like the 2005 Pride and Prejudice. This new adaptation has the potential to become the definitive version, even surpassing the beloved 1995 film.

It remains to be seen if the new Sense and Sensibility will be a truly great adaptation, or simply another mediocre one. However, the fact that we keep revisiting Austen’s story proves its lasting power. The Dashwood sisters’ struggles with love and money clearly speak to people across different times and cultures.

Note: This article was originally published on August 22nd, 2025.

Read More

2025-12-13 15:59