Deadwood’s Canceled Final Season Is Still HBO’s Greatest Fumble

by

I was completely hooked on this HBO show back in the 2000s – it was incredible! But honestly, I was devastated when they suddenly cancelled it. We were all really looking forward to a fourth season and a satisfying ending, and it just felt like we were left hanging. For a while, HBO said they’d wrap things up with two TV movies, but it took over ten years for the show to actually get the conclusion it deserved. Finally, in 2019, a movie came out that gave us some closure, which was a huge relief!

Created by David Milch, Deadwood realistically portrayed a wild and lawless town on the American frontier, blending actual historical figures with invented characters. The show started strong after the fifth season of HBO’s popular The Sopranos, attracting many viewers. But once The Sopranos ended, fewer people tuned in. The third season also didn’t receive the same praise from critics, only earning awards for its technical aspects. Even so, HBO was willing to consider making a fourth season.

Deadwood Almost Had a Fourth Season

According to the book The Deadwood Bible by Matt Zoller Seitz and Jeremy Fassler, HBO contacted David Milch in 2007 about continuing Deadwood with a fourth season. They suggested a shorter season of only six to eight episodes—less than the typical twelve—which would have altered the show’s rhythm, as each episode usually covered a single day’s events.

Though many current TV shows have short seasons, a six-episode order was quite short for dramas in the 2000s. John Milch apparently disagreed with this, believing a full 12 episodes were needed both to properly tell the story and to ensure the crew at Melody Ranch received adequate compensation.

News that a fourth season wasn’t going to happen quickly became public. This leak may have forced HBO’s hand, preventing further discussion. It’s unclear exactly how the information got out or how many episodes were initially considered. However, the result is certain: despite mutual interest in finishing the show, Deadwood never had a fourth season.

The Deadwood Movie Closed Some of the Storylines

Thirteen years after the series ended, Deadwood: The Movie returned to the camp, showing how things had evolved. Early on, Seth Bullock and Alma Ellsworth, who were once lovers, have an uncomfortable reunion at the hotel Seth now co-owns with Sol Star. Although their feelings for each other haven’t faded, Seth is now happily married to Martha, leaving both of them uncertain about how to navigate the situation. Alma, skilled at handling sensitive moments, warmly tells Seth, “I’m genuinely happy to see you again, even though you seem stuck in the past.”

The film immediately establishes that time has passed. The opening line, “Ten years gone,” sets the stage, and characters repeatedly acknowledge the changes around them – Charlie is surprised by new arrivals, and Al Swearengen questions Bullock about his whereabouts. Throughout the story, characters contemplate aging, how things change, and what stays the same. We see Al struggling with illness, Cy is no longer with them, Jane is stuck in her ways, and Seth has matured. In many ways, the film felt like a continuation and a fresh start for the series itself, as much as it was a story about the characters’ lives.

Okay, let’s be honest, this film wasn’t flawless. Some plot points felt a little rushed – Trixie’s confrontation with Hearst, for example, felt shoehorned in, even if it was important for wrapping things up and didn’t quite fit her character. We also didn’t get enough of Molly Parker’s Alma, and it seemed like that was due to scheduling conflicts rather than a natural conclusion to her story. Some supporting characters shone, truly feeling like themselves, while others felt like they were just there for a bit of fan service. But despite a somewhat flimsy plot, the movie really works because it prioritizes the characters and brings a sense of closure to lingering storylines. It’s fascinating to see how Al has evolved – he’s now a U.S. Marshal, successful in both his career and family life with Martha and their three kids. He’s a respected figure in his community, and thankfully, he hasn’t lost his moral center. Alma’s return stirs up some emotions for him, but it doesn’t jeopardize his commitment to Martha, and she, for her part, seems genuinely content with her own achievements.

I’ve been really invested in Trixie and Sol’s journeys this season. It’s amazing to see how much they’ve grown. Trixie used to be so impulsive, but she’s really found herself and gained some self-respect as she prepares to run the Gem. And Jane, who always felt a little lost, finally had this incredible moment where she realized she could be a hero all on her own, with a little help from Charlie and Joanie. Both their stories are about learning to value themselves and finding peace. Old Man Hemlock, though, is a different story. He’s getting frail and it’s clear he doesn’t have much time left. It’s been powerful to watch him go from being the most powerful man in town to someone who needs care, but even then, he still manages to exert influence. His final scenes were just beautiful – so dignified, filled with small moments celebrating family, community, and love. Seeing him support Trixie and embrace the Gem’s future was really touching.

Similar to the original series, the Deadwood movie blends historical facts with fictional storytelling. Creator David Milch thoughtfully explores themes of aging, death, and finding peace, making it a proper send-off to the town and its inhabitants. The ending feels both respectful and emotionally satisfying, offering a meaningful conclusion for almost every character. Though, had the film been produced as a fourth season, the character development and plotlines likely would have been more detailed and complete.

Deadwood Season 4 Could Have Closed the Story Properly

Although important to the larger narrative, Jack Langrishe and his acting group’s story isn’t fully concluded. Season 3 focuses on their efforts to establish a theater in Deadwood, creating dramatic moments due to Jack’s known affairs. The theater eventually opens and seems to thrive, but neither Jack nor the troupe appear in the Deadwood movie, suggesting they simply left town and their fate remains unknown.

The movie also omitted the character Silas Adams. He first came to Deadwood as a messenger for a dishonest official who worked with Al Swearengin, and later became one of Al’s reliable associates. Silas had a difficult relationship with Dan Doherty and frequently irritated Al by sticking up for his unreliable friend, Hawkeye. The film doesn’t explain what became of Silas. Because he wasn’t as devoted as Dan or Johnny, he likely just left Deadwood. Given the risky nature of his job, it’s also possible he was killed somewhere along the way.

David Milch had many ideas for a fourth season of Deadwood, and some of those plans didn’t make it into the show’s finale. The third season showed Al Swearengen losing some of his control over the town to George Hearst, and Milch intended for that trend to continue, mirroring historical events. He planned for Swearengen to rebuild his brothel, The Gem, after a fire—caused by fireworks, according to reports—but never regain his previous level of power. This loss of influence would have worsened Swearengen’s struggles with drinking and violence. In addition to the fire, Milch also imagined a flood affecting Deadwood.

Although the movie included many of his original ideas, like the complicated relationship between Bullock, Martha, and Alma Garrett, it would have been better to tell the full story over a complete season instead of condensing it into a two-hour film. Milch had detailed plans for every character, which would have allowed their stories to finish in a satisfying way. By making it a movie, a lot of potential depth was lost. Another season would have given Milch the chance to fully explore the weakening of Swearengen’s control, the conflict with Hearst, and the fates of all the characters in Deadwood, providing them with the proper endings they deserved.

Read More

2025-10-31 17:09