12 Years Later, The Office Ruining 1 Major Character Remains Unforgivable

by

As a huge fan of comedy, I have to say *The Office* really left its mark. From 2005 to 2013, it was totally addictive – that mockumentary style was so fresh, and it was hilarious, but also surprisingly sweet and relatable. It wasn’t perfect, though. While the final season mostly tied everything up, there was one character whose ending always felt a little unsatisfying to me, and I know a lot of other fans feel the same way.

Even twelve years after *The Office* ended, many fans are still frustrated with how the character of Andy Bernard changed, especially in the final season. Despite Ed Helms being a naturally charming actor, Andy went from being a well-developed and relatable character to someone immature and unpleasant very quickly. It was a disappointing creative choice that could have easily been avoided, and remains one of the most frustrating parts of the show’s ending for many viewers.

Andy Bernard Rose To Become One Of The Most Beloved Characters In The Office

When Andy Bernard first joined the show, he wasn’t very well-liked. He came across as arrogant, frustrating, and deeply flawed, carrying baggage from his transfer from the Stamford office to Scranton. Proud of his Cornell education and desperate to impress his bosses, Andy also struggled with anger, sometimes even damaging property – though Jim’s teasing could push anyone to their limit. Initially, his personality was simply unpleasant, and his insecurities made him difficult to root for. However, after attending anger management, Andy began to change. He gradually became more likable, though he still occasionally sought approval in ways that could be irritating.

Andy, like Michael, had his flaws, but he expressed them in a different way. While Michael was beloved for his unwavering optimism, Andy often seemed to sabotage himself. Fortunately, anger management helped him grow, and he returned as a more understanding, charming, and empathetic person. He found a sweet connection with Erin, who, like him, was a bit of an outsider, especially after his failed and predictably messy engagement to Angela. He genuinely cared for Erin and the rest of the Scranton branch, forming unique bonds with everyone. From his strange acapella scatting to his habit of calling Jim “Tuna,” his quirks became lovable, making him an essential part of *The Office*. His character development was generally seen as positive, but that wouldn’t last.

Andy’s Downfall in The Office Was Hugely Disappointing

After Season 6, Andy’s character took a noticeable downturn. While the show tried different leaders, including Robert California and Nellie Bertram, eventually Andy became manager of the Scranton branch. Unfortunately, the writers changed Andy from a charming and relatable guy into someone unpleasant and selfish. His earlier vulnerabilities morphed into full-blown narcissism and pettiness, making him unrecognizable from the lovable, goofy character fans had grown to appreciate. Previously, Andy could handle challenges with a positive attitude, but as manager, even small issues brought out the worst in him. Whether it was Nellie teasing him or his struggles in Hollywood, these setbacks affected him deeply, and he became increasingly unkind in the later seasons.

Andy Bernard’s decline was particularly upsetting for fans of *The Office*. He started out as a charming and funny character, even being considered as a potential successor to Michael Scott as manager. However, his behavior towards Erin, who had always been kind to him, signaled the beginning of a downward spiral. This became dramatically clear in Season 9 when he abruptly left for a sailing trip, abandoning both his job and girlfriend with little explanation. Despite clearly struggling, Andy refused to accept help, becoming increasingly unpleasant. His actions ultimately led to his firing as manager, the loss of his relationship with Erin, and the derailment of his aspirations to be a singer. The sudden and complete destruction of Andy’s character was a painful surprise for those who had grown to love him.

Ruining Andy’s Character In The Office Is Unforgivable

Everyone acknowledges Ed Helms’ initial awkwardness on *The Office*, but Greg Daniels clearly saw potential in him, leading to a longer role. While becoming manager offered opportunities for comedic development and character growth, Andy Bernard drastically changed for the worse in the show’s final seasons. This was particularly disappointing because many viewers connected with Andy – he was relatable as someone simply trying to find his place in a difficult work environment. Seeing him improve and build relationships was heartwarming, making his sudden turn towards bitterness in seasons eight and nine a real shock. Fans had empathized with his struggles, and witnessing his progress felt like a win for them as well.

Over time, Andy’s likable personality disappeared, and he became mean and self-centered. This was a setback for the show, as Andy Bernard had once been a valuable character. His dramatic change felt unearned and erased years of established growth, and it didn’t contribute to the overall story. Previously, many viewers connected with Andy’s desire for acceptance, making him a relatable figure, and removing that connection was a mistake.

Ed Helms’ Schedule Could Have Contributed To His Character Arc

Finishing a long-running show is always difficult, and often leads to disappointing finales. After nine seasons, *The Office* had a lot of storylines and characters to tie up, and Andy ended up suffering from rushed, poor writing as a result. This was partly due to the sheer number of loose ends the finale needed to address. Another factor was Ed Helms’ busy schedule; he was filming the *Hangover* movies concurrently with Season 9, which also explained why he wasn’t in every episode.

Andy Bernard had the potential to be a much more developed character on *The Office*, but his storyline unfortunately fell flat. Had the show’s schedule allowed for more appearances, writers could have explored ways to redeem him after his troublesome behavior. It’s ironic that he once lamented not knowing when he was experiencing the “good old days,” considering how his character arc ultimately ended. This line actually highlighted the sadness of his journey. While the series finale was generally satisfying, with weddings and Michael Scott’s return, Andy’s disappointing fate remains frustrating for fans, especially those who initially loved him. While uneven character development is common in sitcoms, damaging a well-liked character so close to the end, with no chance for resolution, felt particularly unfair to viewers.

Read More

2025-10-13 03:13