David Cronenberg’s 20-Year-Old, Oscar-Nominated Crime Thriller Is Secretly A DC Movie Masterpiece

by

It used to be expected that if David Cronenberg, known for disturbing and unsettling films, directed a comic book movie, it would be something like *Swamp Thing* or Charles Burns’ *Black Hole*. People familiar with his work might not even know he *has* directed a comic book adaptation, and they’d likely be surprised to learn it wasn’t a horror film. That’s understandable, though, because *A History of Violence* isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when you think of comic book movies.

David Cronenberg’s gripping crime thriller, *A History of Violence*, came out in 2005. It’s based on the 1997 graphic novel of the same name by John Wagner and Vince Locke, originally published by Paradox Press and later by Vertigo—both now part of DC Comics. The film was critically acclaimed, earning an 88% “Certified Fresh” rating on Rotten Tomatoes and winning an Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay for Josh Olson. Many consider it one of the best films of the 2000s, yet it’s surprisingly often overlooked in discussions of great superhero movies, despite lacking any caped crusaders—and that deserves to change.

A History Of Violence Is A Fascinating Family Drama

Tom Stall owns a quiet diner and lives a peaceful life in the small town of Millbrook, Indiana, with his wife, Edie, and their two children, Jack and Sarah. Everyone sees him as a normal, friendly, and easygoing man enjoying a simple Midwestern life. But everything changes quickly when two mysterious strangers enter his diner one evening, looking for a fight.

When Tom saw a terrible crime starting, he immediately decided to intervene. He quickly stopped the criminals, protecting his employees and customers, though he suffered a minor foot injury that required a short hospital stay.

The event makes Tom a hero to those around him, but it also draws the attention of a man named Carl Fogarty from Philadelphia, who claims to have known Tom years ago as someone named Joey Cusack. After discovering troubling details about this “Joey” and seeing how disturbed Tom becomes when confronted with the claims, Edie starts to wonder if she truly knows her husband.

A History Of Violence Is Filled With Tour De Force Performances

Let me tell you, Josh Olson’s script for *A History of Violence* really stands on its own – the Academy recognized it for a reason, and deservedly so. But what *really* elevates the film are the incredible performances. The main cast doesn’t just act the story, they *become* it, and that’s what makes it truly breathtaking.

In his first of four films with David Cronenberg, Jude Law gives a captivating and subtle performance as Tom. Maria Bello is incredibly moving as Tom’s wife, Edie, powerfully showing both her vulnerability and strength as she deals with the profound impact of his choices on their family.

Ashton Holmes delivers a powerful performance as Jack, a character struggling with anger issues who is pushed to his limits by a relentless bully. The situation escalates when Jack learns his father has a hidden, dangerous side. Ed Harris, a four-time Oscar nominee, is particularly chilling as Carl Fogarty, radiating menace with even just a look. But it’s the late William Hurt who truly captivates, earning his fourth Oscar nomination with a single, intensely gripping scene as a figure from Jack’s past.

A History Of Violence Is A Uniquely Suspenseful Mystery

It doesn’t take long to uncover the truth about Tom’s past once the questions start. However, *A History of Violence* is still a compelling mystery, and a very puzzling one at that. It skillfully keeps viewers guessing with its surprising and cleverly deceptive storytelling.

The story unfolds slowly, giving viewers time to really connect with Tom, understand his relationships with his family, and learn about how he’s known in the town of Millbrook.

His courageous act, combined with the violence he used to achieve it, creates a shocking contrast that stays with viewers. As we learn more about Tom, it becomes harder to reconcile his actions with the gentle, family-oriented man he appears to be. Like the character Edie, the audience might struggle to accept the truth, even when presented with clear evidence, making the story’s surprises even more impactful.

A History Of Violence Is A Powerful Meditation On Honesty

Movies often explore deeper themes than what’s immediately visible, allowing viewers to connect with universal ideas. *A History of Violence* is a prime example – a gripping thriller that also offers significant insights, making it a truly essential film.

Ultimately, *A History of Violence* is a story about the power of honesty – a lesson we learn as children. However, unlike shows like *Sesame Street*, this film truly explores the difficult consequences of lying, both to others and to ourselves. It even suggests that Tom, the main character, has lived a lie for so long that he begins to believe it himself, which may be the most damaging outcome of dishonesty.

Interestingly, *A History of Violence* has a lot in common with Sam Mendes’s 2002 film, *Road to Perdition*. Both are strong character studies focusing on protagonists whose hidden pasts negatively impact their families, and both were nominated for Oscars. They also share a publisher: DC Comics’ Paradox Press. However, *A History of Violence* holds a unique distinction: it’s widely considered the last major Hollywood film released on VHS – a notable achievement!

Read More

2025-10-09 04:46