I’ve Heard People Online Call Sinners “A Rip-Off” Of From Dusk Till Dawn, And It Pisses Me Off. Here’s Why

by

These days, I find the internet frustrating because it often upsetts me. Lately, the irritant has been people labeling the show “Sinners” as a copy of “From Dusk Till Dawn.”

By using more formal and less colloquial language, I attempted to maintain the original sentiment while making it easier for a wider audience to understand.

Indeed, it seems we’re discussing similar films. On one side lies a movie that has earned a spot among my all-time favorites, and on the other, a film that was extremely trendy during the ’90s, though perhaps not the best of the decade. Yes, I understand your point – they are both “vampire” movies.

My reaction to that is simply put: So what? Having similarities does not equate to plagiarism. Now let’s talk about an instance of outright imitation – “Snakes on a Train.” As you may have guessed, it’s a blatant imitation of the movie starring Samuel L. Jackson, “Snakes on a Plane.” However, it is not a rip-off of “Sinners,” and it irks me when people make that claim. Here’s why:

1. Snakes on a Train is a clear copy of Snakes on a Plane, borrowing its concept and title.
2. Sinners is an entirely different movie with its own plot and characters.
3. Mislabeling Snakes on a Train as a rip-off of Sinners is incorrect and misleading.

I Feel Like People Who Make This Comment Haven’t Even Watched Sinners

Two fugitive bank robbers, along with a hostage family, travel across the border and unknowingly end up at a strip club. However, they soon realize that this seemingly ordinary bar is actually overrun with vampires, forcing them to engage in a battle for survival.

Intriguing! Allow me to share a storyline I recently encountered titled “Sinners.” Two individuals with a past in crime, yearning for a fresh start, decide to establish a juke joint. However, a vampire trespasses into this new venture, on the hunt for an exceptional musician. As events unfold, this vampire transforms others into its kind. Consequently, our heroes are compelled to engage in a fierce struggle to escape from their now-vampire-infested establishment.

Although these two films have similarities that aren’t immediately apparent, I’ll still take a closer look. The villains are actually brothers in both stories, and the main characters in each film initially know nothing about vampires until they get deeply involved with them. Both movies also tend to focus on one primary location, even though neither could be categorized as “bottle films.

Anyone who watches the movie “Sinners” will undoubtedly focus on its musical elements, as these aspects are so integral to the narrative that those who fail to mention them may not have actually watched the film. This is a challenge for me, because when I hear that “Sinners” is similar to “From Dusk till Dawn,” it creates certain expectations. If someone hasn’t seen “Sinners,” they might approach it with preconceived notions, which isn’t fair because the movie doesn’t warrant such assumptions.

That Said, If They Have Watched Sinners, Did They Just Ignore All Of The Historical And Racial Context?

It’s worth noting that if someone watched Sinners and thought it resembled From Dusk till Dawn, they might have overlooked the rich historical and racial themes presented in the movie. To me, it seems rather difficult to disregard such significant elements within the film.

I wouldn’t categorize “Sinners ” as a typical vampire movie, but rather as a production that incorporates vampires into its narrative. The use of vampires serves more than just to make them appear “cool” – they are metaphors in the story. In fact, it’s not the supernatural elements that make this film stand out, but the story surrounding them. For instance, there’s a poignant scene about racial discrimination that moved my wife to tears, and has nothing to do with vampires per se.

In addition, while Salma Hayek graces the screen in Dawn, the series Sinners emphasizes inclusivity and representation more prominently. It’s worth noting that this diversity is deeply ingrained within the narrative itself, a fact that would likely be recognized, even subconsciously, by anyone who has seen it.

Beyond that point, let me emphasize the significant role of the setting. It seems odd to me that those who compared the movie to “FDTD” would overlook Jim Crow-era Mississippi and its profound influence on the plot. I find it hard to comprehend. In any possible scenario, how could a film as rich as “Sinners” be considered a copy of “From Dusk till Dawn”? I simply can’t fathom it.

I Also Think Calling Sinners “A Rip Off” Of From Dusk Till Dawn Devalues How Awesome That Movie Is, As Well

Perhaps you’re wondering if I dislike “From Dusk till Dawn” or if my statement about preferring “Sinners” implies that I think less of it. That’s not the case at all! In fact, I ADORE “Dawn”, just for different reasons than you might expect.

From Dusk till Dawn,” directed by Robert Rodriguez, known for his legendary work, is primarily an exciting blend of action and horror. It’s not particularly deep or thought-provoking, but it doesn’t need to be. After all, this film boasts a bar named The Titty Twister and features Tom Savini wielding a gun in an unusual location. All these elements make “From Dusk till Dawn” an entertaining and unique cinematic experience.

I have a soft spot for action-packed, bloodthirsty films, as well as vampire movies. I’ve seen every live-action Underworld movie and will watch almost any film featuring blood-drinking creatures. To make a long story short, I adore the movie Dawn, and it might just be my favorite George Clooney film, or perhaps even my top Hayek production (if you’re curious about that).

As a movie enthusiast, I find it regrettable when films like “Dawn” and “Sinners” are hastily compared, as this does a grave injustice to the former. The unique appeal of “FDTD” (First Person Shooter: Time Traveler’s Diary) is undeniable, with its innovative concept such as the “crotch gun,” setting it apart from other productions.

However, I must express my disapproval when “Sinners” is labeled a mere imitation of “FDTD.” Such a statement implies that the originality and badass action-horror elements present in “FDTD” are being overlooked. Frankly, I believe that “Sinners,” despite its similarities, falls short compared to the unparalleled excitement “FDTD” offers as a genre-bending masterpiece.

In The End, This Feels Just Like When People Claimed The Hunger Games Was “A Rip-Off” Of Battle Royale

Back in the early 2010s, when The Hunger Games movies gained massive popularity, there were many online discussions claiming they were essentially a copy of the movie Battle Royale. Since I hadn’t seen or read either at that time, I ended up accepting this as fact. At that point, I was less discerning on the internet and didn’t always know what was true or false.

For a spell, I just went along with things, often saying I was familiar with “The Hunger Games” even if I had no clue about it. But then I watched and read “Battle Royale”, and “The Hunger Games”. It turned out that my assumption, like the one suggesting “Sinners” copied “From Dusk Till Dawn”, was completely off base when I actually experienced both of them.

In terms of their themes, these stories – Battle Royale, The Hunger Games, Sinners, and FDTD – couldn’t be more dissimilar. While they might share a dystopian setting with violent elements, their underlying messages are vastly different. Battle Royale is deeply rooted in Japanese culture, whereas The Hunger Games addresses broader issues of class struggle. Comparing these stories as if they were identical would be akin to oversimplification and ignorance, and I believe the same applies to Sinners and FDTD. There is virtually no similarity between them whatsoever.

What do you think? I’d love to hear your thoughts.

Read More

2025-08-25 17:22