Michael Keaton’s Batman Return Destroys DC Multiverse Continuity

by

Michael Keaton reprised his iconic role as Batman in The Flash after a 31-year hiatus, with surprisingly massive consequences for the DC universe. Keaton first played Bruce Wayne in Tim Burton’s Batman (1989) and Batman Returns (1992). He stepped away from the part when Joel Schumacher became director, and the role was later played by Val Kilmer and George Clooney.

Michael Keaton famously stepped away from playing Batman, supposedly because of disagreements over the character’s direction. However, he surprisingly returned to the role in the 2023 film The Flash, over three decades after Batman Returns. While fans of Tim Burton’s films loved seeing Keaton reprise the part, his appearance ultimately damaged the established storyline of those films, and effectively erased the continuity built by both Burton and Schumacher.

Michael Keaton’s The Flash Return Rewrote The Burton-Schumacher Continuity

The Batman films directed by Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher between 1989 and 1997 had a somewhat disjointed story. The role of Bruce Wayne was played by different actors: Michael Keaton starred in the first two films, Batman and Batman Returns, then Val Kilmer took over for Batman Forever, and finally George Clooney finished the series with Batman & Robin. Despite these frequent cast changes, the filmmakers intended all four movies to be part of a single, continuous storyline.

The four Batman movies made between the late 1980s and 1990s all featured the same version of Bruce Wayne. This is evident because some actors, like Pat Hingle and Michael Gough, appeared in multiple films. Both Batman Forever and Batman & Robin continued the story directly from the previous movies, so Val Kilmer and George Clooney played Bruce Wayne at later stages in his life, building on Michael Keaton’s portrayal.

While Tim Burton’s and Joel Schumacher’s Batman films once had a somewhat connected timeline, the 2023 movie The Flash largely erased that connection. The Flash disregarded the storylines of Batman Forever and Batman & Robin, choosing instead to center on Michael Keaton’s version of Bruce Wayne. The situation became even more confusing when George Clooney, who played Batman in Batman & Robin, made a cameo, suggesting his Bruce Wayne was a separate character from the one portrayed by Keaton in the earlier films.

Okay, let’s talk about how The Flash really messed with the Batman timeline. Honestly, after all the changes they made to Batman’s history, the four movies with Val Kilmer and George Clooney just don’t flow as a proper series anymore – if Clooney’s Batman is now a completely different person, the sequels don’t really connect. It’s like The Flash is saying Batman Forever and Batman & Robin never actually happened for Michael Keaton’s Batman. It’s a total shake-up, and frankly, it’s left fans like me really confused about what actually counts in that series of films.

DC’s Batman ’89 Comics Gave Michael Keaton’s Dark Knight His Own Sequels

Not only did The Flash change the timeline of the Batman films directed by Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher, but it also derailed Burton’s original vision for a third movie. Burton initially intended to make a trilogy, but only directed Batman and Batman Returns. His planned third film would have brought back Michelle Pfeiffer as Catwoman, transformed Billy Dee Williams into Two-Face, potentially featured Robin Williams as the Riddler, and included Marlon Wayans as Robin.

Although Tim Burton didn’t direct a third Batman film, his ideas for it were continued in the comic book series Batman ’89. This comic served as a direct sequel to Batman Returns, using many of the plot points from the movie Burton had planned but never made. Interestingly, Sam Hamm, who co-wrote the original 1989 Batman movie, also wrote Batman ’89.

Batman’s 90s Movie Saga Has One Of The Weirdest Chronologies In The DC Multiverse

The Batman movies directed by Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher in the 1990s have the most confusing timeline of any DC story. The plan was originally for Tim Burton to direct three films starring Michael Keaton, but the third was canceled. Joel Schumacher then directed two sequels with Val Kilmer and George Clooney as Batman, resulting in a series of films that only loosely connect to each other.

Okay, so here’s a really strange bit of movie history. Did you know Halle Berry’s Catwoman was initially supposed to be a continuation of Tim Burton’s Batman Returns? They actually planned to bring Michelle Pfeiffer back as Catwoman! There’s even a quick shot of Pfeiffer in her classic suit hidden in the film as an Easter egg. Obviously, that didn’t pan out, and we got a completely different Catwoman movie. It’s a weird little detail that leaves the film floating somewhere in the confusing timeline created by Burton and Schumacher’s Batman films.

The Arrowverse television series revisited the Batman films directed by Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher during its “Crisis on Infinite Earths” event. In the Batwoman episode, the character meets an older Bruce Wayne (played by Kevin Conroy) who comes from another universe, and it’s likely this version is meant to be an older Michael Keaton’s Batman. The evidence is the Batmobile used by Conroy, which looks very similar to the one driven by Keaton.

Ultimately, The Flash completely reset the timeline established by the earlier Batman films directed by Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher. This has created a confusing and tangled history for all related media – including movies, TV shows, comics, and projects that were started but never finished. Trying to make sense of it all feels like connecting the dots on a wild conspiracy theory, and it’s now incredibly difficult to determine what’s officially part of the story and what’s not.

Michael Keaton Almost Became The DCEU’s Batman

The story of Michael Keaton’s return as Batman in The Flash gets even more interesting when you learn he was once considered to replace Ben Affleck as the main Batman in the DC Universe. When Keaton’s appearance in The Flash was announced, many people—including fans and reporters—thought the “two separate storylines” mentioned by Brooks Barnes (as reported by DenofGeek) meant one would follow Robert Pattinson’s Batman and the other would feature Keaton, with Keaton continuing in future DC films.

Michael Keaton’s time as Batman ended with his appearance in The Flash. It appears he was only ever meant to play the role in that one film. Even if plans had changed, his run as Batman in the old DC Universe would have been short-lived, as The Flash marked the end of Zack Snyder’s vision for those films. Now that James Gunn is leading a new DC Universe, it’s unlikely Keaton will reprise his role as Bruce Wayne.

It likely worked out better that Michael Keaton wasn’t cast as the main Batman in the DC Extended Universe. His involvement would have created a complicated puzzle, forcing the franchise to reconcile the storylines from the earlier Burton and Schumacher Batman films. After The Flash essentially erased the connection to those older movies, rebuilding a consistent timeline would have been a huge challenge. While not the sole reason for the DCEU’s eventual end, it’s ironic that Michael Keaton’s Batman ended up being the one to dismantle the franchise’s multiverse.

Read More

2026-04-13 04:49