6 Supernatural Side Characters Who Must Be in Revival (Who Aren’t Castiel)

Even though it’s been almost six years since the show ended, fans are still eager for a reboot of the popular fantasy series, which left a big mark on pop culture. Both leading actors, Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki, have found success in other projects, but they’ve both said they’d be open to revisiting the roles they’re best known for.

With talk of bringing back Supernatural, many fans are hoping to see familiar faces like Misha Collins as Castiel. Beyond the main characters, viewers would also love to see other supporting characters return. These characters played important roles in the Winchesters’ journeys and the show’s story, and could be key to a successful reboot.

Claire Novak Had an Epic Arc Involving Castiel

Claire Novak first appeared as the young daughter of Jimmy Novak, the man who allowed the angel Castiel to inhabit his body. Years later, she returns as a troubled teenager, angry with Castiel for the hardships she’s faced – including her mother leaving and a childhood spent in foster care. Ultimately, she joins Jody Mills’ family and begins hunting monsters, even though some people disapprove.

Claire is a memorable, though often polarizing, character from Supernatural, known for being strong-willed and blunt. Many fans were hoping for a spin-off series centered around Jody Mills and the young hunters she mentors, including Claire. While she played an important role in Castiel’s story, Claire didn’t appear much in the show’s final seasons, usually only showing up briefly between the main storylines.

While some viewers didn’t connect with Claire and preferred other characters, she remains a compelling figure with a lot of potential. What many people appreciate about her is that she embodies the future of hunting, representing the generation that will carry on after Sam and Dean. If the show ever returns, it’s important that this new generation of characters isn’t overlooked.

Garth Fitzgerald Provides a Much-Needed Perspective on Hunting

Garth is a memorable character, especially considering his debut in a particularly divisive episode. Despite his quirky and unusual methods, he quickly becomes a close friend to Dean, assisting him on multiple occasions. Unlike many other hunters we meet, Garth isn’t conventional, but he consistently defeats his enemies and lives to tell the tale.

Garth experiences a transformation into a werewolf, a fate that usually leads hunters to commit suicide or be killed by their peers to prevent them from becoming the creatures they pursue. However, Garth was different – he managed to control his werewolf instincts. Ultimately, he finds happiness, marrying another werewolf and starting a family, and dedicates himself to helping other werewolves live peacefully alongside humans without causing harm.

Garth is a compelling character because he adds depth and shows that not all creatures are inherently evil, challenging the typical hunter mindset. He helped characters like Dean Winchester realize the world isn’t as simple as they thought, and his presence is key to showcasing the show’s intricate and layered world.

Rowena Macleod Became the Unexpected Queen of Hell

I first learned about Rowena MacLeod as this incredibly old witch, basically surviving for centuries using dark magic. Her initial goal was to free Lucifer from Hell, thinking she could gain something from it. But things changed! She actually became a really powerful ally to Sam and Dean, especially after Lucifer just… got rid of her. She managed to come back, though, using a resurrection spell. It’s also wild to learn she’s Crowley’s mother – he became King of Hell partly just to get back at her for not being around!

Rowena was often a questionable ally to the Winchesters, but she proved incredibly powerful. In the show’s fifteenth season, she made the ultimate sacrifice, taking all the souls of Hell into herself to save Earth. Despite her past misdeeds, this heroic act cemented her place as one of the show’s most memorable and selfless characters.

In a surprising turn of events, Rowena, as Queen of Hell in the show’s final season, actually thanked Sam Winchester for killing her – something she’d specifically asked him to do. She wanted to finally achieve the power she’d always craved, and given her complex character, it felt like a fitting conclusion. Despite this, many fans are hoping she’ll return if the show ever comes back, particularly if there’s another war between Heaven and Hell.

Jack Kline Became the Almighty that Everyone Needed

Jack Kline had a unique and challenging life. He was the son of the devil, Lucifer, and a human mother, Kelly Kline, who died giving birth to him. Appearing as a teenager, Jack always struggled to earn the trust of those around him. He spent his life trying to control his incredible powers and find his purpose.

Jack is a complex character who has stirred up a lot of debate among fans because of his past mistakes, most notably his unintentional role in the death of Mary Winchester. However, he ultimately chose to fight for what’s right, even helping to defeat God when God threatened to destroy everything. After God was gone, Jack stepped up and took on the responsibility of maintaining balance in the world.

Many viewers were hoping for more of the show, but Jack’s storyline received a particularly good ending. Given where he was left at the end of the season, it’s very possible he’ll be involved if Sam and Dean Winchester ever return, as they are currently in Heaven.

Jody Mills Is One of Supernatural’s Best Hunters

Jody Mills, the sheriff of Sioux Falls, faces immense tragedy when she loses both her son and husband to supernatural forces. This shared loss deeply connects her with the Winchesters and Bobby Singer, and she becomes a valued member of their close-knit group. While she sometimes assists them on hunts, Jody ultimately develops into a capable and well-respected hunter herself.

Jody Mills is more than just a recurring character; she’s a genuinely lovable figure who becomes a mother and friend to many. Though she experiences the heartbreaking loss of her own child, she opens her heart and home to Claire Novak, Alex Jones, a girl raised by vampires, and Kaia, who comes from another dimension. By the end, Jody is a haven for dozens of people hurt by the supernatural, offering both honest, direct advice and heartfelt support.

Throughout the fifteen seasons of the show, many side characters appeared, but Jody Mills stands out as a fan favorite, just as popular and important as characters like Bobby Singer and Castiel. Because she’s become such a trusted member of the Winchesters’ inner circle, any continuation of the story would need to include Sheriff Mills.

Ben Braeden Is the Son Dean Winchester Never Had

Ben Braeden was a significant, though often overlooked, character in the series. He was first presented as the son of Lisa, a woman Dean once had a relationship with, and Dean briefly believed Ben was his own child. Although Ben wasn’t actually Dean’s biological son, he became part of the family during Season 6, believing Sam was trapped in Hell. Through his relationship with Lisa and Ben, Dean experienced a glimpse of a normal life before returning to the dangerous world of hunting.

A particularly frustrating moment for many fans was when Dean had Castiel erase Lisa and Ben’s memories of him following a demonic attack. This felt like a disappointing and sad way to conclude their story arc, especially since they’d become so important to Dean. While they weren’t often referenced after Season 6, having a potential family briefly changed Dean as a character.

Fans are hoping a potential revival of the show will explore certain storylines, particularly the relationship between Dean and Ben. While Lisa played an important role, Dean’s close, father-like connection with Ben was truly special. It would be exciting to see Ben return as an adult, maybe even continuing to hunt monsters despite having lost his memories of Dean.

2026-01-08 05:40