6 Most Underrated Mystery Movies Since 2015, Ranked

Recently, several excellent mystery movies have come out, including The Woman in the Window and the 2023 film Missing. However, many great mystery films often get ignored because bigger, more popular movies or those with famous actors tend to get all the attention. Over the last ten years, quite a few deserving mystery films haven’t gotten the recognition they deserve.

Films like Under the Silver Lake and Searching aren’t typical mysteries, but they offer intriguing and captivating stories that keep viewers engaged. The Night House and Watcher are particularly chilling examples of thrillers where the mysteries become more complex as the films unfold. Even when mystery movies break from tradition, they deserve praise for shaping what we expect from the genre today.

Under the Silver Lake Is an Unconventional Missing Person Case

Under the Silver Lake tells the story of Sam, a man in his thirties who is drifting through life with limited goals and financial difficulties. After meeting and connecting with his intriguing neighbor, Sarah, he looks forward to seeing her again. But when Sarah and her roommates mysteriously disappear, Sam embarks on a quest to uncover what happened to her.

Even though Under the Silver Lake received mixed reviews, many think it has the potential to become a beloved cult film within the mystery genre. The story is strange and original, filled with eccentric and unconventional characters who don’t quite fit in. But it’s precisely these unique elements – especially the complex lead character – that make the film so memorable.

Andrew Garfield consistently delivers captivating performances, particularly in films like Under the Silver Lake, where he excels at playing unconventional characters. While the movie’s mystery is unsettling, its unique approach to the genre makes it a truly rewarding watch.

Paranoia Is Validated in Watcher

The thriller Watcher stars Maika Monroe as Julia, an American woman who relocates to Romania with her husband, Francis. He works long hours, leaving Julia alone at home, where she becomes convinced a neighbor is watching her. Her worries are brushed off as paranoia, and she begins to suspect the man might be connected to a recent series of murders.

The movie Watcher offers a unique take on the typical thriller. Instead of following the investigator, it centers on a woman who feels she’s being stalked and the unsettling man observing her. A significant aspect of the film is its portrayal of the dangers faced by women and the frustrating experience of not being taken seriously until something terrible happens.

While other movies featuring Maika Monroe have gotten more buzz, Watcher is a remarkably tense and unsettling film. It expertly builds suspense by showing how Julia’s anxieties grow as the story unfolds, creating a consistently dark and foreboding atmosphere that stays with you long after it ends.

The Clovehitch Killer Hits Close to Home

I was totally hooked by The Clovehitch Killer! It starts when Tyler finds some really unsettling things that make him question his seemingly perfect, all-American dad – you know, the churchgoing, Scout leader type. He teams up with Kassi, who’s a bit of an outsider because she’s obsessed with the Clovehitch Killer case, and together they start digging into the crimes. It’s a really tense story because Tyler’s desperately hoping his dad isn’t involved, and he’s trying to find any way to prove he’s innocent.

Many movies dealing with murderers are unsettling, but The Clovehitch Killer is particularly haunting. Inspired by the BTK Killer, the film doesn’t center on the crimes or the victims themselves. Instead, it focuses on a family member of the killer, offering a close look at how such terrible acts affect those around them.

The novel The Clovehitch Killer is surprisingly effective as a coming-of-age story, centering on a teen grappling with the discovery of his father’s secret life. The mystery surrounding the killer’s crimes is skillfully interwoven with the tension of anticipating how the truth will unfold.

Home Is Not a Safe Place in I See You

“I See You” is a thriller centered around a detective and his wife as they investigate the disappearance of young boys. Strange events in their home lead to suspicion and tension in their marriage. When they begin to suspect their own son may be involved in something awful, they desperately try to hide a terrible secret.

While there are plenty of home invasion thrillers, I See You stands out because it slowly builds suspense. The film doesn’t immediately let the audience know someone is inside the house, creating a feeling of unease and making viewers question everything. Even after the intruders are discovered, the story keeps you guessing with a few lingering mysteries until the very end.

While I See You might not be the most conventional home invasion movie, its unsettling premise – the idea of strangers secretly living in your home – is deeply disturbing. This slow-paced thriller creates a uniquely uncomfortable viewing experience, making it stand out within the genre.

Searching Is a Parent’s Worst Nightmare

This film is a standalone mystery centered around perilous situations faced by teenagers. The story follows David Kim, whose daughter, Margot, disappears. He refuses to accept the investigator’s theory that she ran away and begins his own search, carefully examining Margot’s social media to understand her life and find clues about her whereabouts.

The film Searching is surprisingly complex. While it appears to be a simple story about a parent looking for their missing child, it delivers a powerful message about the risks of the internet. It highlights how easily people can be deceived online and cautions parents to be more aware of their children’s online activity.

Despite being a strong film, Searching is often missed when people talk about thrillers. It’s not a typical horror movie, but it’s a gripping look at a frighteningly common situation: a teenager being manipulated into danger. The film feels very realistic, and it’s important to remember that this could happen to anyone, even adults.

The Night House Subverts Expectations In the Best Way

The Night House tells the story of Beth, who is devastated when her husband, Owen, unexpectedly dies by suicide. As she grieves and tries to cope with the loss, she starts experiencing strange and unsettling events. These occurrences lead her to question her own mental state and wonder if Owen was hiding a dark secret from her.

The Night House is a gripping and frightening horror film – easily one of the scariest released in recent years. It follows Beth as she uncovers disturbing secrets about her late husband, all while being targeted by a terrifying supernatural force. These two frightening elements turn out to be connected in a way that ultimately reveals more about Beth herself.

Despite its dark subject matter, the film is surprisingly moving, scary, and ultimately rewarding. It’s a powerful story about grief and how discovering hidden truths about those we’ve lost can be another form of trauma. The mystery expertly blends with these themes without overshadowing the film’s supernatural and psychological aspects.

2025-12-14 19:13